Top 10 Best Tow Behind Plug Aerator Reviews

by Truman Perkins

Reading this article intensively is assume that you are a garden freak and want a serene gardening experience for your own. But sometimes, due to excessive pedestrian traffic or the hammering of severe storms, your lawn may eventually get squashed. In addition, the compacted soil makes it difficult for water, nutrients, and air to reach your lawn's root systems. So, you need the best tow behind the plug aerator for proper treatment of the soil. This allows the grass to get the nutrients it needs, grow deeper roots, and make the best water and fertilizer use.

The best tow behind plug aerator is an important gardening apparatus for effectively aerating your lawn grass. We have gone through the numerous types of devices and recommend the best tow behind plug aerators and some of the finest in this article.

Top Tow Behind Plug Aerator by Editors

10 Best Tow-Behind Plug Aerator Reviews

10 Best Tow-Behind Plug Aerator Reviews
10 Best Tow-Behind Plug Aerator Reviews

1. "Agri-Fab" 48-Inch Tow Plug Aerator, Orange & Black

Agri-Fab 45-0299 48-Inch Tow Plug Aerator,Orange & Black,Large
Agri-Fab 45-0299 48-Inch Tow Plug Aerator,Orange & Black,Large

The Agri-Fab, Inc. A fabulous 48-Inch plug aerator tow behind to groom your lawn to look better in no time. This aerator loses the soil in your lawn to allow necessary air, water, and nutrients to pierce. As a result, the device will let your lawn grow strong and healthy, giving your lawn a professionally groomed look that you have been waiting for. This heavy-duty tow behind plug aerator has a weight tray that can tolerate the pressure up to 175 lbs. for added soil penetration.

The machine has 32 self-sharpening plug aerator knives on the unit. A 9 3/4″ x 2 3/4″ flat-free tires allow for smooth carriage, require less maintenance, and can attach a plug aerator to any tractor.


  • 32 Galvanized knives;
  • Weigh up to 175 lbs.
  • 48-inch plug aerator;
  • Easy transport and handling;
  • High quality galvanized aerator knives;
  • Flat-free wheels;
  • Universal fit hitch.
  • The assembling will be a problem for new users.

2. "Strongway" Tow-Behind Plug Aerator - 48in.

Strongway Tow-Behind Plug Aerator - 48in.W, 32 Coring Plugs
Strongway Tow-Behind Plug Aerator - 48in.W, 32 Coring Plugs

If you want to groom your garden on your own, the Strongway is the best choice for your lawn soil. This best quality tow behind plug aerator has a 48in. Wide, bring out 32 coring plugs that penetrate up to 2 1/2in. Deep, even in compacted soil. The aerator ensures the perfect flow of water and nutrients down to the roots of plants in the soil.

It has separate coring plug spikes that penetrate a depth up to 2 ½ in. weight tray and supports to hold up to 140 lbs. It also has 10in. Pneumatic tires roll smoothly over the varied landscape. The Pin-style universal hitch allows for quick and easy hitching, removal on ATVs, or riding lawn mowers, with no additional equipment necessary.


  • Durable steel plates that hold up to 140lbs;
  • 10-inch numeric tire for a smooth ride;
  • Adjust handle from tractor seat for convenience;
  • Towable by ATV or lawn tractor.
  • Sharp and durable spikes
  • reduce soil compaction
  • Easy to handle and clean
  • The pin-style universal hitch design
  • No straps included for securing extra weight

3. "Brinly" PA-48BH Tow-Behind Plug Aerator

Brinly PA-48BH Tow Behind Plug Aerator, 48-Inch
Brinly PA-48BH Tow Behind Plug Aerator, 48-Inch

Aerating, fertilizing, or adjusting the pH of your soil is a must-do task for your lawn to thrive. So why do these work separately when you have the Brinly PA-48BH plug aerator tow behind in your hand.

A two-in-one machine helps you maintain your lawn better, whether it's with grass seeds or fertilizer in the spring or lime in the fall. This best tow behind plug aerator lets you aerate and spread one coarse material at a time. The device has galvanized star-shaped tines that can penetrate up to 2 inches of compacted soil and a heavy-duty steel hopper that can store up to 120 pounds of spreading material.

This best quality tow behind plug aerator can get your hands on if you don't mind paying a little more attention. A flow control mechanism on the device allows you to generate spread patterns to reduce waste. Just keep in mind that the lever swings a little freely.


  • 16-gauge Steel plugging spoons;
  • holds up to 200 pounds of any extra weight;
  • 10″ semi-pneumatic rubber tread tires
  • Allow easier penetration and require less weight.
  • Long-lasting construction made with durable steel;
  • Easy handle and transportation;
  • Universal hitch pin
  • Assembling is a little more complicated.

4. "Precision" 42-Inch Plug Aerator

The Precision Products PA42GY 42-inch tow behind core plug aerator loosens soil and allows nutrients to reach your grass' roots by removing plugs from your yard. It's an ideal gauge for use in clay soils, high-traffic areas like playgrounds, and sports fields. The machine is also working effectively in burnt-out and damaged lawn. It holds thirty-two-gauge steel plugging spoons that can penetrate as deep as 2-1/2 inches in the soil.

On two 10-inch pneumatic tires with steel wheels, the aerator moves effortlessly. It has a metal towing bar and can be attached to a practically mowing tractor. A single-action level, conveniently accessible from the tractor, engages or disengages the aerator with a single pull. To maximize penetration, an 11-gauge steel tray contains an extra 150 pounds of weight.


  • Steel body(42-inch-wide);
  • Can hold up to 150-Pound capacity;
  • 32 plugging spoons;
  • Single lever action control;
  • 42-inch plug aerator;
  • Penetrates up to 2-1/2 inches with 32 plugging spoons;
  • Easy-to-use with single-lever action;
  • Solid steel construction for strength, durability.
  • Easy Assembling;
  • Easy to move and durable body;
  • Universal hitch.
  • Scarcity of replacement parts

5. "Yard Tuff" SE-40 Drum Spike Aerator

Yard Tuff SE-40 Drum Spike Aerator
Yard Tuff SE-40 Drum Spike Aerator

The Yard Tuff SE-40 Drum Spike Aerator is the best quality tow behind plug aerator for packing and aerating your soil. The 36-inch operating breadth of this tool allows for rapid and efficient operation. The 78 spikes penetrate up to 2.5" deep into the ground to properly aerate your soil. In addition, the drum contains 24 gallons of water, allowing you to go even deeper for optimum air exposure.


  • 78 heavy-duty spikes penetrate up to 2.5″ into the ground
  • Heavy-duty steel for a durable and reliable product;
  • Tows behind ATVs, UTVs, or lawn tractors with the pin-style hitch;
  • A capacity of 24 gallons and weighs 299 lbs.
  • Allows nutrients to seep into your soil
  • keeping it healthy and performing well
  • Easy to attach and easy to use for a hassle-free product
  • Ideal for use with looser soils higher in sand concentrations
  • Recommended for use with a 14 HP or larger tractor
  • Assembling might get tuff

6. "Master Rancher" Tow Behind Lawn Aerator

Master Rancher YTL-008-030 Tow Behind Lawn Aerator
Master Rancher YTL-008-030 Tow Behind Lawn Aerator

If you must be confused about what is the best tow behind plug aerator? The Master Rancher is the best for you. It features a rust-resistant coating finish and a single-hand lift lever. This tow behind plug aerator spreader adjustable with lawn/garden tractors and ATVs / UTV'S. The single-hand lift lever to engage and disengage wheels. It contains a 1/2″ pin type tow hitch, and the steel plug spikes resist damage from or rocks & roots. It holds up to 140 lbs of soil, and it has 32 replaceable Plug spike.


  • Depth: 3″ Tire / Wheel size: 10″ Pneumatic.
  • Working width: 48″
  • Rust-resistant powder coat finish;
  • 1/2″ pin type tow hitch
  • Plug spikes resist damage from or rocks & roots
  • Single hand lift lever to engage and disengage wheels
  • Easy Tow-Behind Aerating
  • Smooth-Rolling Design
  • Efficient and Effective
  • Customizable Working Weight
  • Shorter tines only pull soil cores to a depth of 2.5 inches

7. "Agri-Fab" 40-Inch Spike Aerator, Black

Agri-Fab 45-0544 40-Inch Spike Aerator, Black
Agri-Fab 45-0544 40-Inch Spike Aerator, Black

Agri-Fab 45-0544 Drum Spike Aerator is ideal for aerating and packing the soil. This machine has a 40 in. lawn spike aerator that provides up to 2.5 in. of aeration depth. In addition, it contains adding up to 100 lb. to the weight tray. When you aerate your lawn, you open up the soil surface to let grassroots get the air and moisture they need for healthy growth.


  • 40" working width of this spike aerator;
  • Aerator spike comes pre-assembled;
  • Two 7" flat-free tires make for smooth transport;
  • Can hold Up to 100 lbs.
  • Easy raising and lowering the knives.
  • The universal hitch fits any lawn tractor, regardless of brand.
  • Maximizes the affected area
  • The aerator spike comes pre-assembled
  • Saves valuable assembly time
  • Simple-to-use
  • The lever to raise and lower aerator knives can be difficult to operate

8. "Brinly" Behind Double Tow Bar, 40″ Spike Aerator

Brinly SA2-40BH-P Behind Double Tow Bar, 40' Spike Aerator, Hammered Black
Brinly SA2-40BH-P Behind Double Tow Bar, 40' Spike Aerator, Hammered Black

Brinly, one of the best brands in the market now. It has 10 tine stars with 8″ diameter spike tips to penetrate soil up to 2″ In-depth. It allows water, seed, and nutrients to reach the roots. The patent-pending 3-D tines in galvanized steel inhibit rust and resist bending, even in compacted soil. The machine has durable construction and an all-steel design with reinforced side plates, a 5/8 in. solid steel axle, and a double tow bar for extra strength.

The rigid weight tray holds up to 110 pounds of extra weight for maximum penetration. Each 8" diameter star rotates independently and continues revolving during tractor turns. A single, heavy-duty universal Hitch is attached for easy connection to any rider or tractor like ZTR or ATV. The package includes a manual with parts break down and full pictorial assembly instructions.


  • Deep penetration;
  • Durable construction and Galvanized steel body;
  • 5/8 inch solid steel axle;
  • Carry 110 pounds of extra water;
  • Independent star rotation
  • Easy rotation, move and handle
  • Each plugging spoon
  • Assembling is easy
  • Wheels are in an outboard position when lifted, can bend easily

9. "Brinly" AS-40BH-A Tow Behind Combination

Brinly AS-40BH-A Tow Behind Combination, 40-Inch Aerator Spreader, Black
Brinly AS-40BH-A Tow Behind Combination, 40-Inch Aerator Spreader, Black

The combo of aerator-spreader drops seed, fertilizer, or lime while you aerate to expedite your time on the lawn. This best tow behind plug aerator can hold up to 100 lb. (1.74 cu. ft.) of soil; the durable steel hopper prevents twisting and flexing for long-lasting durability. In addition, heavy-duty spacers provide maximum strength and dependability.

Featuring 132 tine tips, the 8″ diameter galvanized steel stars rust and perforated the soil up to 2″ deep. It provides access for air, water, and nutrients to the root system. The flow control feature includes an adjustable stop to ensure accurate spread patterns with minimal waste.


  • Heavy Tubular Design:
  • A solid tine shaft ensures maximum dependability.
  • 9 in. x 1.75 in. transport wheels to cross driveways and sidewalks with ease.
  • Can hold up to 100 lb. of soil;
  • Easy to lift and handle
  • Flow control system attached.
  • Galvanized body construction
  • Tractors can be cumbersome when fully weighted

10. "Agri-Fab" 16-Inch Push Spike Aerator, Black

Agri-Fab 45-0365 16-Inch Push Spike Aerator,black
Agri-Fab 45-0365 16-Inch Push Spike Aerator,black

The Agri-Fab 16-Inch Push Spike Aerator must have your lawn looking better in no time. The machine helps to loosen the soil to allow air, water, and nutrients to reach the root system. The best time to aerate your lawn is in the spring because it opens up the compacted soil. Thus, allowing your lawn to grow strong and healthy, giving your lawn a professionally groomed look you have been wanting.

The spike aerator has 5 galvanized spike disks to penetrate the soil easily. Each spike disk on the push aerator has a 2.5" aeration depth. The 16" working width is perfect for smaller lawns and hard-to-reach places. In addition, the Spike Aerator with a 35 lb. capacity weight tray easily increases soil penetration.


  • Walk-behind spike lawn aerator;
  • 16 inch wide; 5 aerating wheels with 7-inch spikes;
  • Expose grass to air, nutrients, and water; 2-1/2-inch aeration depth;
  • Steel weight tray holds concrete block, creates pressure, and pushes spikes into the ground;
  • Easy Handling
  • Quick and smooth-rolling
  • Long-lasting
  • Universal hitch
  • Some assembly required

What to Consider

The biggest entity to consider when choosing a tow behind a plug aerator is the size of your lawn. While for small lawns, you may use manual options that necessitate you to push the tines into the ground. They are easy to store, affordable, but they're not very practical for larger yards. Tow-behind options are much less work, although you'll need a tractor or riding mower to pull them. It's also significant to remember that all lawns are different, so if you're not sure if aeration is the right move or you don't have the time, it may make more sense to hire a professional.

How To Prefer The Best Tow-Behind Plug Aerator

Ease of Movement

Maneuverability, a term pretty much important to choose a tow behind a plug aerator spreader. Your machine needs to be able to move across your lawn with ease. It means that you need to consider the scheme of its wheels. Can the machine move in between narrow spaces? Can it take sharp corners effortlessly?

Aerator Width

There are multiple factors to consider when choosing a plug aerator tow behind. One of the first options is the size of your property. For larger properties, a wider tow behind the core plug aerator will result in fewer passes. But if you have a lot of tighter spaces, a smaller unit may make more sense.

Number of Core Aeration Spoons

The metal shaft that enters the soil is often called a spoon. The more of these spoons in your aerator, the more cores it will remove on each pass. Aerators with a larger tow behind the lawn plug aerator usually have more cores.

Max Core Depth

It's important to recall that the purpose of a heavy-duty tow behind a plug aerator is to increase air and water penetration while also fostering deeper root development. As a result, the amount of dirt removed will resolute by the depth at which your aerator spoons are intended to dig.

Pneumatic vs. Flat-Free Tires

Tires are pneumatic, which means they are filled with air. They give a supple feel but are prone to flattening. Newer "flat-free" tires are built of solid polyurethane and do not deflate; however, they are more costly. These are usually more expensive.


Think about this. You buy an aerator only for it to evolve some mechanical difficulties after 2 days of use. It won't give you value for your money, which is an important factor to consider when buying anything. A machine that attributes a firm body like steel, reinforced or galvanized, equals durability.


For many decades, the cost has been a determining feature when considering buying something. However, the concern is; would you go for an expensive aerator or an inexpensive one? Of course, there are mixed reactions to this query, but consumers always balance high-quality to high price often influences them.

Of importance, you need to consider that cheap can be expensive, but this isn't necessarily true for tow-behind plug aerators.

Load Capacity

The other essential thing that you should consider when searching for a tow behind the core plug is the load capacity. Here, it would help if you questioned how much additional load the machine can add. Does it have leeway for this load? Having a space for additional weight means that your tool will pierce deeper when aerating.


Choosing the best tow behind the plug aerator will be subject to your needs. This includes the extent of your yard and whether or not you have a lot of landscaping to maneuver around.

Make your decision based on your needs, not marketing hype. These are all quality tow behind lawn plug aerators, and each of them can serve your needs. What's important is that once you have this tool. You begin putting it to regular use, improving the quality of your soil.


About Truman Perkins

Truman Perkins has worked as the SEO consultant for over a decade; there he's helped so many startups and friends' sites get off the ground. Believing gardening is a natural stress reliever, Truman indulges in learning and writing about gardening in his free time. He lives with his wife, Jenny, and their twins in Detroit, Michigan.

Thoughts on "Top 10 Best Tow Behind Plug Aerator Reviews"